Coney Island Homes for Sale

Coney Island Homes for Sale

Welcome to Coney Island, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Treasure Island, Florida, within the picturesque Pinellas County. This charming subdivision offers a delightful blend of coastal living and suburban tranquility, making it a sought-after destination for those looking to call Florida home.

Coney Island is renowned for its inviting atmosphere, where palm trees sway gently in the warm Gulf breeze and the sound of waves lapping at the shore creates a soothing backdrop to daily life. Residents enjoy a close-knit community feel, with friendly neighbors and a vibrant local culture that makes every day feel like a vacation. The subdivision is just a stone's throw away from some of Florida's most beautiful beaches, providing endless opportunities for sunbathing, swimming, and enjoying water sports.

For those seeking homes for sale in Coney Island, you’ll find a diverse selection of properties that cater to a variety of tastes and lifestyles. From charming beach cottages to modern single-family homes, each residence is designed to embrace the coastal lifestyle while offering comfort and style. Many homes feature stunning views, spacious layouts, and outdoor spaces perfect for entertaining or simply soaking up the sun.

Coney Island is not just a place to live; it’s a community where families can thrive, retirees can relax, and everyone can enjoy the beauty of Florida’s Gulf Coast. Whether you’re looking for your forever home or a vacation getaway, Coney Island promises a lifestyle filled with sunshine, serenity, and the joys of coastal living. Discover your dream home today in this enchanting subdivision!

Newest Coney Island Homes for Sale

$1,299,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Coney Island SubDv. ⋅ 33706 Zip Code
Pre-Construction. To be built. **Prime Gulf Coast Lifestyle Opportunity** Brought to you by Seasafe Homes on this expansive 1½ lot, 59' x 105' with over 6k sq ft makes it large enough for a Pool addition. From your front door it's a short walk to the soft, white sands of Treasure Island Beach or enjoy a short stroll to the famed John's Pass Village, a premier destination attracting millions annually, featuring over 120 shops, restaurants, live entertainment & waterfront attractions - dolphin tours, tiki boat cruises, parasailing, jet ski rentals and more. The Salt Cove by Seasafe Homes is thoughtfully designed to deliver exceptional strength, energy efficiency & comfortable coastal living in a more compact footprint. Offering 1,650 square feet of well-planned living space, this 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom home combines modern functionality with the durability needed coastal living. Built with a robust 2x10 floor system and 2x6 exterior walls, the Salt Cove is engineered to withstand wind speeds up to 180 MPH exceeding the typical 150 MPH standard and providing added confidence in hurricane-prone regions. Using SeaSafe's Two-Site build process, build times can be reduced by up to 75% compared to traditional site builds, allowing homeowners to enjoy their new home sooner and protecting your home from the elements during construction. Inside, the open-concept design creates a bright and inviting atmosphere, seamlessly connecting the kitchen, dining, & living areas for everyday living and entertaining. The kitchen features ample storage, modern finishes, and a functional layout that makes the most of the home's efficient design. The primary suite offers a private retreat with a spacious bedroom, well-appointed bathroom, & generous walk-in closet. Two additional bedrooms provide comfortable accommodations for family, guests, or a home office, while the convenient half bath adds flexibility for entertaining. Faster. Stronger. Elevated. The Salt Cove is built to help you enjoy more of what matters most. Renderings are for illustrative purposes only and may include optional or upgraded features. Seasafe Homes also has 11 other Pre-Engineered floor plans available and ready to go if the Salt Cove isn't exactly what you're looking for. This incredible location is just a short drive from downtown St. Petersburg, where you'll find the St. Pete Pier, world-renowned museums like the Dali and Chihuly collections, as well as a vibrant arts scene, sport & concert venues, and an array of fine dining, including Michelin-starred restaurants.

108 125th Avenue, Treasure Island
$1,250,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Coney Island SubDv. ⋅ 33706 Zip Code
5-bedroom, 3-bath luxury coastal residence located less than 800 feet from Treasure Island beach, offering an elevated blend of personal retreat and income-producing potential. Refined, light-filled living and dining spaces create a sophisticated setting for entertaining, anchored by a well-appointed kitchen with generous storage and prep areas. The bedroom configuration is designed for comfort and privacy, featuring a serene primary suite complemented by spacious guest rooms to accommodate families and larger groups. Thoughtfully curated outdoor areas capture the coastal lifestyle, with inviting spaces to lounge, dine, and unwind after a day on the sand. With its scale, polished finishes, and premier proximity to the shoreline, this property functions equally well as an upscale primary residence, luxury vacation home, or high-performing short-term rental. Currently operating as a very profitable income-producing short-term rental.

12201 Gulf Boulevard, Treasure Island
$3,250,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Coney Island SubDv. ⋅ 33706 Zip Code
Own one of Treasure Island's rarest beachfront compounds. Featuring The Pink Flamingo and The Blue Dolphin—two fully renovated Gulf-front homes generating nearly $300,000 in annual gross rental income—this turnkey legacy property offers the perfect blend of luxury living, proven cash flow, and irreplaceable direct beach frontage. Celebrated for their distinctive 1950s retro coastal theme, The Pink Flamingo and The Blue Dolphin have become iconic beachfront destinations, where vintage Old Florida charm meets modern comfort. Every detail has been thoughtfully designed to capture the nostalgia of a bygone era while providing today's guests with the quality and amenities they expect. The result is a truly memorable experience that has earned nothing but 5-star reviews and a loyal base of repeat visitors who return year after year. Behind the timeless aesthetic lies a property that has been meticulously updated for peace of mind and long-term value. Both homes feature impact-rated windows and doors, combining enhanced storm protection with energy efficiency, quiet interiors, and abundant natural light—all while preserving their unique character and curb appeal. With an established rental business, proven financial performance, and nearly $300,000 in annual gross revenue, you'll step into immediate cash flow while enjoying the flexibility to use the property however you choose. Live in one home and rent the other, continue operating both as premier vacation rentals, or create the ultimate multi-generational beachfront retreat for family and friends. The Pink Flamingo offers spacious accommodations, vibrant retro-inspired décor, and breathtaking Gulf views that make every stay unforgettable. Just steps away, The Blue Dolphin complements the experience with its own distinctive personality and inviting atmosphere, creating the perfect pairing for larger groups, extended families, or dual rental opportunities. Together, they form a one-of-a-kind beachfront compound that simply cannot be replicated. Step outside and the Gulf of Mexico becomes your backyard. Spend your mornings with coffee overlooking the water, your afternoons with your toes in the sugar-white sand, and your evenings watching spectacular sunsets from your private beachfront oasis. It's the quintessential Florida lifestyle that guests rave about and one that few properties can truly offer. For investors, the value extends well beyond the real estate itself. You're acquiring an established hospitality business with a proven operating history, exceptional guest satisfaction, and a recognizable identity that sets it apart in a competitive market. The combination of all 5-star ratings, repeat clientele, and turnkey operations provides a solid foundation for continued success from day one. Perfectly situated in the heart of Treasure Island, you're just minutes from waterfront dining, shopping, boating, entertainment, and John's Pass while still enjoying the privacy and tranquility of direct beachfront living. Properties offering two separate Gulf-front homes, a proven six-figure income stream, distinctive branding, modern upgrades, and an irreplaceable location are extraordinarily rare. The Pink Flamingo and The Blue Dolphin are more than vacation rentals—they are beloved destinations that blend nostalgia, luxury, and investment potential into one unforgettable opportunity. Note - There is also a second lot included that is in front of the lot with the houses.

12609 Sunshine Lane, Treasure Island
$1,400,000
6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ Coney Island SubDv. ⋅ 33706 Zip Code
LEGAL WEEKLY RENTAL DUPLEX just steps from the sugar-white sands of Treasure Island. This unique income-producing property is being offered as the entire duplex featuring 6 bedrooms, 5 full baths and 2 half baths with 2,252 square feet of living space (2,863 gross square feet). Each side of the property functions as a private rental unit (A & B), while an adjoining interior hallway with locking doors allows both units to be opened and combined, creating one large residence ideal for large groups, family retreats, or maximizing vacation rental income. Recent improvements include all new flooring throughout both units, brand new appliances and cabinetry in each kitchen, and fresh interior paint throughout. Located on a quiet island street approximately 100 steps to the beach, with easy access to restaurants, boating, fishing, and everything that makes Treasure Island one of Florida’s most desirable Gulf Coast destinations. An exceptional opportunity for vacation rental investors or buyers seeking a flexible beach property with strong income potential.

115 124th Avenue W, Treasure Island
$699,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Coney Island SubDv. ⋅ 33706 Zip Code
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Island Living Meets the Ultimate Florida Beach Lifestyle! Welcome to 112 119th Avenue in the highly desirable community of Treasure Island. This exceptional Triplex property offers the perfect blend of Island living, and beach-town charm in one of Florida's most sought-after coastal destinations. Located just steps away from the sugar-sand beaches of Treasure Island, you'll enjoy endless opportunities for boating, fishing, kayaking, paddleboarding, dolphin watching, and breathtaking Gulf Coast sunsets. The nearby John's Pass Village & Boardwalk features over 100 shops, restaurants, waterfront dining venues, fishing charters, dolphin cruises, parasailing adventures, and year-round entertainment, making it one of the area's premier attractions. Outdoor enthusiasts will love the nearby Treasure Island Beach Trail, perfect for walking, jogging, biking, and taking in spectacular Gulf views. Residents also enjoy easy access to Sunset Beach, local parks, waterfront dining, and some of the best recreational boating waters on Florida's Gulf Coast. Conveniently located near downtown St. Petersburg, residents can enjoy world-class dining, museums, sporting events, and vibrant nightlife while still returning home to the relaxed coastal atmosphere that makes Treasure Island so special. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence, vacation home, or investment opportunity, this Triplex offers an incredible opportunity to experience the Florida waterfront lifestyle you've been dreaming about. Come discover why so many people choose Treasure Island as their place in the sun. Live where others vacation and make every day feel like a getaway. Embrace this vibrant coastal lifestyle in this turnkey triplex, where paradise meets profitability. The buyer is to verify all measurements, zoning, and rental restrictions. Unit #1 featuring 1 bedrooms and 1 bath Unit #2 featuring 2 bedrooms & one bath Unit #3 featuring 1 bedrooms and 1 bath

112 119th Avenue, Treasure Island
Start Your Search